Stop the attempt to cancel the 5 November Momentum National Committee!

Some members of the Momentum national Steering Committee are proposing postponing the 5 November National Committee meeting. There is an attempt to call an “emergency” Steering Committee meeting tonight, 28 October, in order to postpone the NC.

This is beyond absurd. Momentum has not had a National Committee meeting since May (six months – and what months!) The July NC was cancelled and attempts to call a meeting in August or September voted down by the Steering Committee. Then a date was set in October and moved repeatedly. The date 5 November has now been out for five weeks (see here), and Momentum groups and regions around the country have been preparing for it. Many will also have booked train tickets, taken time off work, and so on.

The stated reason from the Steering member proposing this, Sam Wheeler, is that 5 November is the North West regional Labour Party conference. But, again, 5 November has been set for five weeks. Why has this just been “discovered” now?

The May NC voted to hold a democratic national conference in February, but preparations for this conference have barely advanced. There is still no date. If the NC is postponed, I predict attempts to postpone or cancel the conference. In any case, delaying the NC will make moving forward with organising the conference even more difficult.

It is not unreasonable for the Steering Committee to sometimes take the initiative in changing the date of the NC. It is unreasonable for it to effectively prevent it from meeting over and over again.

Lastly, and this is not insignificant, the Steering Committee meeting tonight has been called at 21 hours notice, with the call going out at 9.45pm on Thursday night. This is in itself ridiculous and undemocratic. Several members of the Committee, including FBU General Secretary Matt Wrack, cannot be there. Several of us, including Matt and myself, have argued that the meeting should not take place.

It is ironic that a movement which says it wants a democratic Labour Party and labour movement should face these kinds of problems – problems which are indicative of a much wider lack of democracy in Momentum.

Please feel free to send me your view at and I will pass on. I will be fighting for the 5 November NC to go ahead.


2 thoughts on “Stop the attempt to cancel the 5 November Momentum National Committee!”

  1. Politics should be about issues, not personalities but what has Momentum been about (or mostly about) for the whole of its existence?

    Jeremy Corbyn.

    Momentum has yet to espouse a broad, issue-based progressive agenda that other candidates not named Corbyn could pick up and run with in their localities unlike the successor organization to Sanders’ presidential campaign, Our Revolution. The issue-based differences between Corbyn and his opponents (particularly Owen Smith) were never night-and-day contrasts nor polar opposites; instead, the Labour Party’s leadership contest was more about personalities and personal histories than policy.

    Now that the Labour Party’s leadership contests have finally ended for the foreseeable future, Momentum no longer has any oxygen to sustain its frantic mobilizations on behalf of dear leader Corbyn. Momentum has been pushed into its first (and probably last) existential crisis because today the task facing revolutionaries is not to wage an intra-Labour struggle but to build a viable, effective opposition to May and the Tory government.

    The best possible outcome would be if an issue-based organization or a policy-driven group oriented towards build a credible and effective opposition to Tory rule (and in Scotland, SNP dominance) emerges out of Momentum’s self-destruction. Unfortunately, this outcome seems very unlikely given Momentum’s cultish political culture that renders it incapable of managing or even tolerating differences of opinion, the sine qua non of all genuinely democratic politics.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s